BY JENNIFER JACOBS
REGISTER STAFF WRITER

Every time a grocery shopper uses a food stamp debit card in an Iowa supermarket, the state’s taxpayers fork over more money for the transaction than anywhere else in the country.

The Iowa tab for taxpayers: $1 million a year.

“It’s a waste of tax dollars,” said Roger Munns, a spokesman for the state Department of Human Services, which has been trying to persuade lawmakers to end the practice for four years.

Only six states pay grocers anything for the service. Iowans pay the most: 7 cents per swipe.

Gov. Chet Culver sees this as a problem.

But grocers are digging in their heels. They say there is an expense for grocers to operate the swipe machines at the checkout counter, so the reimbursement is justified.

What action lawmakers might take, if any, is up in the air.

Three Democratic leaders in the Iowa Statehouse said they either weren’t familiar with what DHS calls the “grocer subsidy,” or have never been personally approached about ending it.

A fourth, Michael Gronstal, the majority leader in the state Senate, said Thursday he isn’t in favor of getting rid of the fee.

“From my perspective, those other states that do that, they basically make all of you pick up the tab for the cost of processing those transactions. You end up covering that when you pay for your food,” Gronstal said. “It ends up being just a hidden tax.”

Retailers let customers use their bank debit cards and credit cards for free, and recover their costs with the price of groceries. Food stamp users are the only ones charged a fee, and the bill goes to the government, said Kevin Concannon, DHS director.

Half of the bill, about $506,000 a year, is paid by the state. The federal government pays an equal amount.

Hy-Vee, an Iowa-based company that does business in several states that don’t reimburse for this expense, declined to comment Thursday.

Jerry Fleagle, president of the Iowa Grocery Industry Association, said nearly all of its 600 grocery store members, including Dahl’s, Wal-Mart and Aldi, are opposed to eliminating the fee.

Retailers are charged, on average, just over 8 cents per swipe machine transaction, so the government reimbursement doesn’t cover the expenses, Fleagle said.

If a food stamp debit card transaction does not go through - for example, the customer doesn’t have enough money on the card - the store still pays a fee, but does not get reimbursed, he said.

And grocers usually make less on food stamp customers than on others, Fleagle said. That’s because most food stamp users buy food staples. Grocers’ profit margins on those basics are normally lower than on steaks, prepared foods and items higher-income shoppers purchase, he said.

Munns said food stamp users don’t have as much to spend individually, but the items they choose are often the same high-markup processed foods that others buy.

The grocer fee was designed to ease the transition from food stamp coupons to debit cards, which is now complete nationwide. Iowa food stamp users spend $24 million a month in groceries, according to the state. That’s double the level in 2003, when coupon use ended in Iowa.

Federal regulations for food stamps still permit the payment to grocers, but Iowa is one of the few states that still has a law that requires it.

Fleagle said for DHS to refer to the reimbursement as a subsidy is “a joke.”

“Members of the Iowa Legislature, when explained this issue, have supported keeping the reimbursement fee,” Fleagle said. “They understand it, and get it. And I am not talking a few of them. More like 90 percent.”

Culver, for the first time, cut the payment from his budget for the coming year.

Former Gov. Tom Vilsack also supported getting rid of it.

Concannon, the DHS director, believes the grocer fee is discriminatory. “When I use my Visa card to purchase food at those same stores, Visa doesn’t pay a subsidy to the stores for my use. Rather, the store pays Visa a fee,” he said.

Concannon proposes giving the money the state saves to food banks or to help the poor, elderly or disabled.

Sen. Jack Hatch, a Democrat from Des Moines, said Thursday the fee will come up soon in the Health and Human Services budget subcommittee, which has lawmakers from both the House and Senate.

The two top leaders in the House, Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy and House Speaker Pat Murphy, said Thursday they’re willing to take a look at it and keep it on the table.

Reporter Jennifer Janeczko Jacobs can be reached at (515) 284-8127 or jejacobs@dmreg.com

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]